Australia ▾
  Australia   New Zealand
Join Now

Home | Price List | Contact

Login
Forgot your password?
  • Trust

    Trust

    • Acknowledgement of Trust (already own asset) - $165
    • Change Appointor and/or Guardian of Family Trust - $110
    • Change of Name of Family Trust - $110
    • Change Trustee of Family Trust - $110
    • Dealing with Forgiven Debts (White Paper) - $55
    • Debt Recognition (including pre-Div 7A Loans) - $33
    • Declaration of Trust (before you buy) - $110
    • Div 7A Loan Agreement - $65
    • Div 7A Loan Agreement for UPE - $65
    • Family Trust - $165
    • Family Trust - Streaming & Bamford Update - $165
    • Family Trust - Update to Allow Change of Appointor and Guardian - $165
    • Family Trust - Update to allow Sole Trustee - $55
    • Family Trust - Update to Exclude Foreign Persons (NSW) - $198
    • Family Trust - Wind up/Vesting - $259
    • Forgiveness of Debt - $121
    • Opening Minutes for the Unit Trust - $33
    • Partnership Deed - $220
    • Release of Unpaid Trust Entitlement - $121
    • The new small business restructure roll-over rules in practice (White Paper) - $55
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2008/09 - $99
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2009/10 - $99
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2010/11 - $99
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2011/12 - $99
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2012/13 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2012/13 - Single-Use - $110
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2013/14 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2013/14 - Single-Use - $110
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2014/15 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2014/15 - Single-Use - $110
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2015/16 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2015/16 - Single-Use - $110
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2016/17 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2016/17 - Single-Use - $110
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2017/18 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2017/18 - Single-Use - $110
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2018/19 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2018/19 - Single-Use - $110
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2019/20 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2019/20 - Single-Use - $121
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2020/21 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2020/21 - Single-Use - $121
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2021/22 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2021/22 - Single-Use - $121
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2022/23 - Multi-Use - $363
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2022/23 - Single-Use - $132
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2023/24 - Multi-Use - $363
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2023/24 - Single-Use - $132
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2024/25 - Multi-Use - $363
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2024/25 - Single-Use - $132
    • Unit Trust - $165
    • Unit Trust - Add New Member Kit - $110
  • Superannuation

    Superannuation

    • Acknowledgement of Trust (already own asset) - $165
    • Commercial Lease - $275
    • Declaration of Trust (before you buy) - $110
    • Derivative Risk Statement for SMSF - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 15/16 - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 16/17 - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 17/18 - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 18/19 - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 19/20 - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 20/21 - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 21/22 - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 22/23 - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 23/24 - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 24/25 - $65
    • Pension Pack for Self Managed Super - $299
    • Product Disclosure Statement (general) - $66
    • Product Disclosure Statement (Pension only) - $99
    • Self Managed Superannuation Fund Deed - $165
    • SMSF - Minute to Appoint Administrator - $33
    • SMSF - Minute to Appoint an Auditor - $33
    • SMSF - Minute to Approve Financial Statements - $33
    • SMSF - Minute to Insure The Members - $33
    • SMSF - Update Rules - $165
    • SMSF Limited Recourse Borrowing Arrangement - $330
    • SMSF Restricted Commercial Property Assessment - $695
    • SMSF Restricted Residential Property Assessment - $315
    • Statutory Declaration - $0
  • Estate Planning

    Estate Planning

    • Codicil to change the Executor - $99
    • Confidentiality Agreement (Non Disclosure) - $99
    • Debt Recognition (including pre-Div 7A Loans) - $33
    • Enduring Power of Attorney - NSW - $55
    • Enduring Power of Attorney - SA - $55
    • Enduring Power of Attorney - WA - $55
    • Enduring Power of Attorney (Financial, Personal/Health) - QLD - $55
    • Enduring Power of Guardianship - NSW - $55
    • Enduring Power of Guardianship - WA - $55
    • Power Of Attorney By Company - $99
    • Will - Married or Defacto No Children - $95
    • Will - Married or Defacto with Children - $95
    • Will - Single No Children - $110
    • Will - Single With Children - $110
  • Commercial

    Commercial

    • Advanced Legal Health Check for Businesses - $18
    • Buy a House with Friends Agreement - $110
    • Commercial Lease - $275
    • Confidentiality Agreement (Non Disclosure) - $99
    • Co-Owners Agreement - $110
    • Dealing with Forgiven Debts (White Paper) - $55
    • Debt Recognition (including pre-Div 7A Loans) - $33
    • Declaration of Trust (before you buy) - $110
    • Demand and Statement of Claim for Debt - NSW - $88
    • Demand and Summons for Debt - VIC - $88
    • Demand and Summons for Debt - WA - $88
    • Div 7A Loan Agreement - $65
    • Div 7A Loan Agreement for UPE - $65
    • Forgiveness of Debt - $121
    • Loan Agreement (No Security) - $110
    • Release of Unpaid Trust Entitlement - $121
    • Statutory Declaration - $0
    • The new small business restructure roll-over rules in practice (White Paper) - $55
  • Employment

    Employment

    • Confidentiality Agreement (Non Disclosure) - $99
    • Employment - Conduct Issues Letter - $33
    • Employment - Employee Expenses Policy - $55
    • Employment - Performance Issues Letter - $33
    • Employment - Request for Medical Information - $33
    • Employment - Termination Letter - $33
    • Employment - Transferring Employee Letter - $33
    • Employment Contract - $120
    • Independent Contractors Agreement - $110
    • Partnership Deed - $220
    • Statutory Declaration - $0
  • Company

    Company

    • Acknowledgement of Trust (already own asset) - $165
    • Adopt Committee Recommendations kit - $33
    • Appoint a Committee kit - $33
    • Appoint an Alternate Director kit - $33
    • Appoint Managing Director & Confer Powers kit - $33
    • Buy a House with Friends Agreement - $110
    • Change Registered Office kit - $33
    • Commercial Lease - $275
    • Company (ELodgement) - $716
    • Company (No Elodgement) - $99
    • Company Constitution Update - $99
    • Confidentiality Agreement (Non Disclosure) - $99
    • Co-Owners Agreement - $110
    • Debt Recognition (including pre-Div 7A Loans) - $33
    • Declaration of Trust (before you buy) - $110
    • Demand and Statement of Claim for Debt - NSW - $88
    • Demand and Summons for Debt - VIC - $88
    • Demand and Summons for Debt - WA - $88
    • Director‘s Indemnity Agreement - Compulsory Insurance - $197
    • Director‘s Indemnity Agreement - No Insurance - $197
    • Div 7A Loan Agreement - $65
    • Div 7A Loan Agreement for UPE - $65
    • Employment Contract - $120
    • Family Trust - Wind up/Vesting - $259
    • Forgiveness of Debt - $121
    • Independent Contractors Agreement - $110
    • Loan Agreement (No Security) - $110
    • Minutes for Members to Inspect Books - $33
    • Minutes for Resigning Director - $33
    • Opening Minutes for the Unit Trust - $33
    • Partnership Deed - $220
    • Power Of Attorney By Company - $99
    • Release of Unpaid Trust Entitlement - $121
    • Remove a Managing Director kit - $33
    • Remove and Replace a Director kit - $44
    • Replace Company Secretary kit - $44
    • Self Managed Superannuation Fund Deed - $165
    • Statutory Declaration - $0
    • Transfer of Shares Kit - $0
    • Unit Trust - $165
    • Unit Trust - Add New Member Kit - $110
  • CPD Webinars

    CPD Webinars

    • CPD Webinar - End Of Financial Year SMSF Planning 2025 - $110
    • CPD Webinar - End Of Financial Year Tax Rollup 2025 - $110
    • CPD Webinar - Tax and Cryptocurrency – A Square Peg in a Round Hole - $110
    • CPD Webinar - Unlocking Microsoft 365 Copilot - $110
    • CPD Webinar - UPEs and Div 7A – Implications of the Recent Bendel Decision - $110
    • CPD Webinar - When Directors are Personally Liable - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - Foreign Trust Taxation Issues - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - Advising on Family Trusts in the 21st Century - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - AI in Professional Practices - Risks and Benefits - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - Drafting Estate Planning Documents to meet Litigation Risks - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - Employee Share Schemes - $99
    • Webinar On Demand - Family Law and Trusts - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - How Binding are Financial Agreements - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - Professional Advisers as Appointor of their Client’s Family Trust - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - Recent Changes in Family Law - $99
    • Webinar On Demand - Sexual Harassment Laws in Australia - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - Tax & Family Trusts - $99
    • Webinar On Demand - Testamentary Trusts 101 - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - Trust Distributions and Section 100A - $99
    • Webinar On Demand - When Directors are Personally Liable - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - Where Death Benefit Nominations Go Wrong - $110
  • All documents

    All documents

    • Acknowledgement of Trust (already own asset) - $165
    • Adopt Committee Recommendations kit - $33
    • Advanced Legal Health Check for Businesses - $18
    • Appoint a Committee kit - $33
    • Appoint an Alternate Director kit - $33
    • Appoint Managing Director & Confer Powers kit - $33
    • Buy a House with Friends Agreement - $110
    • Change Appointor and/or Guardian of Family Trust - $110
    • Change of Name of Family Trust - $110
    • Change Registered Office kit - $33
    • Change Trustee of Family Trust - $110
    • Codicil to change the Executor - $99
    • Commercial Lease - $275
    • Company (ELodgement) - $716
    • Company (No Elodgement) - $99
    • Company Constitution Update - $99
    • Confidentiality Agreement (Non Disclosure) - $99
    • Co-Owners Agreement - $110
    • CPD Webinar - End Of Financial Year SMSF Planning 2025 - $110
    • CPD Webinar - End Of Financial Year Tax Rollup 2025 - $110
    • CPD Webinar - Tax and Cryptocurrency – A Square Peg in a Round Hole - $110
    • CPD Webinar - Unlocking Microsoft 365 Copilot - $110
    • CPD Webinar - UPEs and Div 7A – Implications of the Recent Bendel Decision - $110
    • CPD Webinar - When Directors are Personally Liable - $110
    • Dealing with Forgiven Debts (White Paper) - $55
    • Debt Recognition (including pre-Div 7A Loans) - $33
    • Declaration of Trust (before you buy) - $110
    • Demand and Statement of Claim for Debt - NSW - $88
    • Demand and Summons for Debt - VIC - $88
    • Demand and Summons for Debt - WA - $88
    • Derivative Risk Statement for SMSF - $65
    • Director‘s Indemnity Agreement - Compulsory Insurance - $197
    • Director‘s Indemnity Agreement - No Insurance - $197
    • Disclaimer - Email - $55
    • Div 7A Loan Agreement - $65
    • Div 7A Loan Agreement for UPE - $65
    • Employment - Conduct Issues Letter - $33
    • Employment - Employee Expenses Policy - $55
    • Employment - Performance Issues Letter - $33
    • Employment - Request for Medical Information - $33
    • Employment - Termination Letter - $33
    • Employment - Transferring Employee Letter - $33
    • Employment Contract - $120
    • Enduring Power of Attorney - NSW - $55
    • Enduring Power of Attorney - SA - $55
    • Enduring Power of Attorney - WA - $55
    • Enduring Power of Attorney (Financial, Personal/Health) - QLD - $55
    • Enduring Power of Guardianship - NSW - $55
    • Enduring Power of Guardianship - WA - $55
    • Family Trust - $165
    • Family Trust - Streaming & Bamford Update - $165
    • Family Trust - Update to Allow Change of Appointor and Guardian - $165
    • Family Trust - Update to allow Sole Trustee - $55
    • Family Trust - Update to Exclude Foreign Persons (NSW) - $198
    • Family Trust - Wind up/Vesting - $259
    • Forgiveness of Debt - $121
    • Independent Contractors Agreement - $110
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 15/16 - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 16/17 - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 17/18 - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 18/19 - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 19/20 - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 20/21 - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 21/22 - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 22/23 - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 23/24 - $65
    • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 24/25 - $65
    • Loan Agreement (No Security) - $110
    • Minutes for Members to Inspect Books - $33
    • Minutes for Resigning Director - $33
    • Opening Minutes for the Unit Trust - $33
    • Partnership Deed - $220
    • Pension Pack for Self Managed Super - $299
    • Power Of Attorney By Company - $99
    • Product Disclosure Statement (general) - $66
    • Product Disclosure Statement (Pension only) - $99
    • Release of Unpaid Trust Entitlement - $121
    • Remove a Managing Director kit - $33
    • Remove and Replace a Director kit - $44
    • Replace Company Secretary kit - $44
    • Self Managed Superannuation Fund Deed - $165
    • SMSF - Minute to Appoint Administrator - $33
    • SMSF - Minute to Appoint an Auditor - $33
    • SMSF - Minute to Approve Financial Statements - $33
    • SMSF - Minute to Insure The Members - $33
    • SMSF - Update Rules - $165
    • SMSF Limited Recourse Borrowing Arrangement - $330
    • SMSF Restricted Commercial Property Assessment - $695
    • SMSF Restricted Residential Property Assessment - $315
    • Statutory Declaration - $0
    • The new small business restructure roll-over rules in practice (White Paper) - $55
    • Transfer of Shares Kit - $0
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2008/09 - $99
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2009/10 - $99
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2010/11 - $99
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2011/12 - $99
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2012/13 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2012/13 - Single-Use - $110
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2013/14 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2013/14 - Single-Use - $110
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2014/15 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2014/15 - Single-Use - $110
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2015/16 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2015/16 - Single-Use - $110
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2016/17 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2016/17 - Single-Use - $110
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2017/18 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2017/18 - Single-Use - $110
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2018/19 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2018/19 - Single-Use - $110
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2019/20 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2019/20 - Single-Use - $121
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2020/21 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2020/21 - Single-Use - $121
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2021/22 - Multi-Use - $350
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2021/22 - Single-Use - $121
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2022/23 - Multi-Use - $363
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2022/23 - Single-Use - $132
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2023/24 - Multi-Use - $363
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2023/24 - Single-Use - $132
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2024/25 - Multi-Use - $363
    • Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2024/25 - Single-Use - $132
    • Unit Trust - $165
    • Unit Trust - Add New Member Kit - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - Foreign Trust Taxation Issues - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - Advising on Family Trusts in the 21st Century - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - AI in Professional Practices - Risks and Benefits - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - Drafting Estate Planning Documents to meet Litigation Risks - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - Employee Share Schemes - $99
    • Webinar On Demand - Family Law and Trusts - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - How Binding are Financial Agreements - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - Professional Advisers as Appointor of their Client’s Family Trust - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - Recent Changes in Family Law - $99
    • Webinar On Demand - Sexual Harassment Laws in Australia - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - Tax & Family Trusts - $99
    • Webinar On Demand - Testamentary Trusts 101 - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - Trust Distributions and Section 100A - $99
    • Webinar On Demand - When Directors are Personally Liable - $110
    • Webinar On Demand - Where Death Benefit Nominations Go Wrong - $110
    • Will - Married or Defacto No Children - $95
    • Will - Married or Defacto with Children - $95
    • Will - Single No Children - $110
    • Will - Single With Children - $110
  • Bulletin

Top 3 Docs Quick Launch

Create New Company Create New Family Trust Create New SMSF

New Release

Trust Distribution Minutes Library for 2024/25 - Multi-Use
View Full Range

Join
it's free

Join Now Join Now

Need legal advice or a specially customised legal document?

Contact our partner law practice

Click here to arrange a quote

Support - Help is here

Support
help is here

  • FAQ
  • Enquire Online
  • Contact Us
Print Version Back

I read it on the internet so it must be true

Issue: 404 - Wednesday, 29 February 2012

In this Issue

  1. I read it on the internet so it must be true

1. I read it on the internet so it must be true

Question: Hi Brett, as do many people who manage their own self-managed super funds (SMSF) – I subscribe to several information sources to keep me informed. One of the providers I subscribe to said that permissive SMSF deeds are problematic. They say that a permissive SMSF deed can prevent the trustee of a fund from paying anti-detriment payments. They also say that some High Court case means that the trustee of a SMSF cannot have any discretion in making decisions.

This doesn’t sound right to me, but then, I am no tax lawyer. Is this a valid argument? Or am I being lead up the garden path?

Platinum Member Sydney, NSW

Answer: In the modern age of online publication, it is common to find very legitimate looking publications on the internet. Many such publications are produced by reputable practitioners in their respective fields. Unfortunately, some publications are not. The problem for SMSF trustees is that they often do not know the reputation of the authors of online publications.

Unlike the more traditional form of publication of information – such as in academic journals, industry journals, industry magazines and financial newspapers – online publication does not encounter barriers like peer review, blind reviews and independent fact checking.

It is easy for people searching out information on the internet to get caught up in a flash, official looking website and assume from the appearances alone that the information is as impressive as the website.

Permissive SMSF deeds cannot pay anti-detriment payments

I have had the opportunity to consider the online bulletin/alert you have referred to. From my 23 years of practicing in taxation and superannuation law, I have found that permissive documents allow for greater flexibility to adapt to changes with minimal adjustment. Essentially, permissive documents generally allow scope for your legal documents to continue to be effective when the law changes.

If we contrast regimented SMSF deeds and permissive SMSF deeds, the main difference is clear. Regimented SMSF deeds require almost constant monitoring, review and updating to keep pace with changes to the legislation and case law. That only causes you, the consumer, to pay more money to lawyers, like me, to keep your legal documents up to date and ensure future compliance with the laws.

Training Video

» Click here to view

While I do like to keep myself busy, to be honest I became a lawyer to help people and not set them up to be a continual source of income.

The anti-detriment payments are a bonus payment made to the dependant of a deceased member of an SMSF or to the deceased member’s estate. Section 295-485 Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (ITAA 97) says that the death benefit payment made to the dependant or estate of the deceased member can be increased by the amount of the contributions tax paid by the member during their lifetime. Such a payment results in benefits to the beneficiaries of the payment and also to the SMSF. The SMSF benefits from being able to realise a larger tax deduction for having made the bonus payment.

For example if the deceased member paid $50,000 in contributions tax during their lifetime and the SMSF trustee makes the bonus payment of $50,000 to the dependant or to the estate, the SMSF claims a tax deduction for the payment in the sum of $333,333 ($50,000 / 0.15).

Whether an SMSF deed is drafted in a regimented way to specifically address the making of anti-detriment payments or whether the SMSF deed is drafted in a permissive way to allow the trustee to make the payment as it is permitted under the ITAA 97, the end result is the same. Namely, that the trustee in fact has the power to make the anti-detriment payment providing they can make the payment without drawing from the member balances of other members. The only real difference is that in the event the law changes regarding anti-detriment payments, the regimented SMSF deed requires reviewing and amendment, whereas the permissive SMSF deed may not.

The real bone of contention regarding making anti-detriment payments is how the payments are to be funded. Regimented deeds and permissive deeds each face the same issues in that regard.

Our beloved Platinum Members discover the tricks of funding anti-detriment payments to death benefit beneficiaries.

Platinum Members, click here to view content

Has the High Court killed off the SMSF Trustee’s discretion?

It has been said elsewhere that the High Court decision of Finch v Telstra Super Pty Ltd [2010] HCA 36 (the Finch case) has removed the ability of SMSF Trustees to exercise discretion when making decisions about the management of the Fund and Member Benefits. It has also been said that in the Finch case, the High Court did not look at any other documents other than the SMSF deed to determine the governing rules of the fund.

In fact, the decision made by the High Court in the Finch case has a very narrow application. The decision said that even though the wording of the SMSF deed may appear to confer discretion on the Trustee to make a decision, in certain limited circumstances the Trustee does not actually have an unfettered discretion. Rather, the Trustee’s decision making ability is impacted by obligations in the s 52 SIS Act and s 14 Superannuation (Resolution of Complaints) Act 1993 (SRC Act).

That means despite what may be contained in the SMSF deed – the discretion conferred on the Trustee is fettered by the obligation to:

… exercise, in relation to all matters affecting the entity, the same degree of care, skill and diligence as an ordinary prudent person would exercise in dealing with property of another for whom the person felt morally bound to provide.

and by the ability of the members of the fund to seek review of decisions made by the Trustee to the Superannuation Complaints Tribunal – if the members think the decision is unreasonable.

In the Finch case, the High Court did not decide that the principles established in Karger v Paul [1984] VR 1 – regarding the immunity of a trustee’s decisions from external review – did not apply to all decisions made by SMSF Trustees. Rather, the High Court said the principles from Karger v Paul do not apply where the decisions specifically affect the member’s entitlements in the Fund, as such decisions may be reviewable where the Trustee did not properly inform himself / herself prior to making the decision. The High Court explicitly stated that “[to] offer answers to wider questions which might arise in disputes different from the present where it is not necessary to do so would have an unsettling effect on the law which may not be beneficial.”

What does this mean for drafting SMSF deeds?

The Finch case merely confirms what most SMSF practitioners already knew. That is, regardless of what is said in the SMSF deed, the Trustee remains subservient to the overarching duties contained in the SIS Act, Tax Acts and SRC Act. Regardless of whether a regimented or permissive SMSF deed is used, or how the SMSF deed is worded, the Trustee cannot escape the duties imposed by the relevant legislation.

In my view, SMSF deeds that are drafted in a permissive way offer the Trustee of the SMSF greater flexibility and reduced ongoing costs to constantly review and maintain the governing rules of the fund. Rather than being proscriptive and stuck in a particular moment in time, permissive deeds change with the legislation by automatically adopting changes to the law.

If you require legal advice regarding what you are permitted to do as a Trustee of a SMSF, contact me, Brett Davies, on (08) 9460 5046 or Brett.Davies@civiclegal.com.au and you can have access to one of my Superannuation experts.

Build these documents now:

  • MySF Manager - DIY Edition (SMSF Software)
  • Self Managed Superannuation Fund Deed
  • SMSF - Deed Update
  • SMSF - Guide to Transacting with your own Fund
  • Investment Strategy for Self Managed Super 10/11

Read these bulletins now:

  • ATO conducting audits Christmas Day
  • Strategies to test if a Super Fund is up-to-date
  • Your SMSF - farce and formalities
  • Make love, not war - to your auditor

Keywords: Tax agents, agent, taxation, accountant, ATO, audit, Self Managed Superannuation Fund, SMSF, SMSFs, Super, Superannuation, voluntary disclosure, auditor, compliance, lodge, lodgement, obligations, incorrect, correct, income, expenses, report, reporting, field, visit, offices, returns, income, ITR.


  • Legal Documents Online
  • Trust
  • Superannuation
  • Estate Planning
  • Commercial
  • Employment
  • Company
  • CPD Webinars
  • All Documents
  • Price List
  • Join Us
  • Join for Free
  • Memberships
  • About Law Central
  • About Us
  • * Our Guarantee
  • Printing and Binding
  • Site Map
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Support
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Feedback
  • Connect
You should follow us on Twitter Subscribe to our RSS feed Follow us on Linked In Subscribe to our Legal Bytes channel

Copyright © 2000-2025 Law Central Co Pty Ltd ABN 98 091 824 225
Site Map | Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer